I admit to being a fan of Stauskas, which I have to admit, probably does influence me. But I'll say it once again, I liked Payton a lot too. Just thought Stauskas was a better fit at the time. Stauskas athleticism is brought up from time to time, and like most things, it's generalized to a large extent, and is governed by perception to some extent. Somewhere along the line, someone thought he was just another slow white guy that couldn't jump. Once introduced, it spreads and is expanded upon. Now I'm not going to sit here and tell you that Stauskas is a great athlete, but I will tell you that he's an above average athlete, for what that's worth. The bottom line is, does athleticism, or lack thereof, affect the players ability. Obviously it can, and the less athleticism a player has, the more skills he needs to overcome it. Thus you have players like Miller who is a very effective player.
But first lets do a comparison to see how Stauskas fares against some other players that are perceived to be above average athlete's. The measurement's I'm using are from the combine.
Nik Stauskas: 6'6.5", 207 lbs, max vertical 35.5", max reach 11'5.5", agility test 10.79, sprint 3.27
Dante Exum: 6'6", 196 lbs, max vertital 34.5", max reach 11'5.5", agility test 10.75, sprint 3.19
Zach Lavine: 6'5.75", 181 lbs, max vertical 41.5" max reach 11'9.5", agility test 10.42, sprint 3.19
Marcus Smart: 6'3.25", 227 lbs, max vertical 36", max reach 11'3", agility test 10.82, sprint 3.26
Of this group Lavine is considered an elite athlete, while Smart and Exum are considered good athletes. As you can see, Stauskas results hold up pretty well against this group. I'll be the first to admit that this isn't an exact science, and the combine results don't tell the whole story, but they're at least an indicator of what group a player falls into. How that shows up in results if yet to be determined. You can be extremely fast, have the ability to jump out of the building, and have poor lateral quicknes. You might not be fast, but quick, with a quick first step. My point is, athleticism doesn't come with a full bag. You can be the greatest athlete in the world and be stupid.
Anyway, in Stauskas case, I don't think athleticism is a problem. Lack of strength is, and hopefully he'll remedy that this offseason. Whatever the outcome, he's being paid less than half of what Landry is being paid. That's more upsetting to me. I can live with cheap mistakes, but the expensive one's are irritating.